Moulded vs Extruded Silicone: Process Selection for Seals, Tubing and Profiles

HOME >> BLOG

Moulded vs Extruded Silicone: Process Selection for Seals, Tubing and Profiles

Time:2026-11-14
Read:12

For any silicone component that is long and constant in cross-section, extrusion is usually the lowest-cost route; for anything with three-dimensional features or tight tolerances, moulding is the only reliable one. The conclusion for buyers: choose extrusion when the profile is uniform and the part is measured in metres, choose moulding when geometry or tolerance drives function, and treat spliced extruded rings as a separate quality decision rather than a cheap substitute for moulded ones.

What each process can and cannot do

Extrusion pushes uncured compound through a shaped die and cures it continuously, typically in a hot-air tunnel or a salt bath. The die costs a fraction of a mould, and production runs as a continuous length that is cut to size. The constraint is fundamental: the cross-section must be constant along the length. Any groove that starts and stops, any boss, any varying wall, is outside what a die can produce.

Moulding forms the part in a closed cavity, so geometry is limited only by tooling and demoulding. The cost structure is the reverse of extrusion: higher tooling, higher piece price at low volume, but the ability to hold tolerances, produce 3D shapes, and combine features in one part.

Comparison at a glance

FactorExtruded siliconeMoulded silicone
ToolingDie, typically low cost and fast to makeMould, higher cost, longer lead time
Pricing basisPer metre or per cut lengthPer piece
GeometryConstant cross-section onlyFree 3D geometry, undercuts, inserts
Typical toleranceLooser; ISO 3302-1 extrusion classes applyTighter; moulded classes apply
LengthContinuous, cut to orderLimited by cavity and press
Surface finishGood but die-line visibleControlled by tool finish
Best forCord, tube, edge trim, weatherstrip, sheetGaskets, boots, seals with features, parts with inserts
Weak pointCut ends, splices, tolerance stack over lengthTooling cost, flash, mould life

Tolerances: the number that decides arguments

Extruded profiles are usually specified against ISO 3302-1, which separates moulded and extruded classes and then grades them by dimension size. In practice this means an extruded cord of 6 mm nominal may carry a tolerance roughly twice as wide as the same dimension on a moulded part. Buyers who copy a moulded drawing tolerance onto an extrusion RFQ create a specification no extruder can hold at a sensible price, and the resulting debate consumes weeks.

The right approach is to specify function first. If the profile is a compression seal sitting in a groove, the critical dimension is the free height that determines squeeze, not the overall width. State the squeeze requirement, allow the looser class on non-functional dimensions, and the price usually drops immediately.

Where extruded rings fail: the splice

O-rings and closed-loop seals are often made by cutting extruded cord and vulcanising the ends together. This is legitimate and widely used, but the splice is a genuine weak point and should be specified explicitly. Three questions decide quality: is the splice hot-vulcanised or merely glued; is the joint offset within an agreed limit; and is the tensile strength at the joint tested, or only the base material.

For static sealing at moderate pressure, a good vulcanised splice performs acceptably. For dynamic sealing, high pressure, or any safety-related application, a moulded ring is the correct choice and the price difference is justified. Ask the supplier which method they use for the size you need — some sizes are only practical moulded, others only spliced, and a supplier who answers vaguely is likely outsourcing the step.

Cost logic in practice

Extrusion economies come from length, not from piece count. A 2-metre length of profile costing a few dollars can yield dozens of cut pieces, so the per-piece material cost is small; the real cost sits in cutting, inspection and packing. That is why an extruded part quoted at 5,000 pieces is not automatically cheaper than a moulded one: at that volume the moulding tool is still being amortised, but the cut-and-inspect labour on the extruded part is not trivial either.

A useful rule of thumb for the first conversation: below roughly 3,000 pieces of a simple constant-section part, extrusion usually wins; above that, moulding starts to compete on total cost, and above roughly 20,000 pieces moulding almost always wins for parts under 200 mm. Geometry can overturn the rule in either direction, so request both quotes when the part is close to the boundary.

Specifying either route properly

  • Cross-section drawing with all dimensions and a tolerance class named by standard, not by habit.
  • Compound and hardness, with cure system stated, since peroxide-cured extrusion is common and has a different odour profile.
  • Colour with a physical reference, because extruded colour varies along a long run and a mid-run sample is the fair comparison.
  • Cut length and end condition for extruded parts: clean cut, chamfered, or spliced, with a length tolerance.
  • Packing format: coil, straight length, or bagged pieces, because a 100-metre coil and 100 straight 1-metre lengths handle very differently at your line.
  • Test requirements, particularly splice strength and compression set if the part seals.

FAQ

Can you extrude a profile with a lip that only runs along part of the length?

No. A die produces a constant cross-section. If the lip must start and stop, the part becomes a moulded item, or a two-piece assembly of extruded profile plus moulded end caps.

Is extruded silicone food-safe?

The process does not determine compliance; the compound does. Food-contact grades are extruded routinely for tubing and sheet. Ask for the specific grade's test report for your market rather than assuming extrusion implies industrial-only material.

Why is my extruded cord harder to assemble than the sample?

Usually tolerance stack over a long cut length, or cure variation along the run making the ends stiffer. Ask for a length tolerance and a hardness check at both ends of the coil, not just at the middle.

Can moulded and extruded parts be combined in one assembly?

Yes, and it is often the best-value design: an extruded profile for the long run plus a moulded corner or end cap, bonded or mechanically joined. This is a common approach for enclosures and protective trim.

Next step

Send the cross-section and the annual length or piece count, and we will tell you which route the geometry supports before quoting. Our custom silicone OEM and ODM service covers both, with reference parts in silicone outdoor products and silicone kitchen products.

Related products